Mccloskey is an australian philosopher who wrote a number of atheistic works in the 1960s and 70s including the book god and evil (nijhoff, 1974) in this article, mccloskey is both critical of the classical arguments. In discussing the presence of evil mccloskey makes the point of various types of evils with various degree of impact to further justify his claims for not believing in god's existence. Mccloskey says that we must conclude from the existence of evil that an omnipotent, benevolent god. Furthermore, mccloskey speaks on the problem of evil and how the existence of evil disproves the reality of a god near the end of mccloskey's article, he also insists that atheism is comforting, claiming that it is more comforting than theism. Suppose that any free being god created would eventually misuse free will regardless of the world that god created49 in such a scenario god could only prevent evil by not creating free beings the world that mccloskey suggests proposes this exact scenario.
According to mccloskey's line of argument, it is possible to argue that god certainly does not exist the world is so imperfect to be the engineering work of a perfect being in fact, we can only conclude that god, if he ever exists, is an evil god since there is more pain and suffering in the world than joy and happiness. Mccloskey goes onto describe evil as the main reason why people turn away from religion and so if god is using it to try and inspire veneration, then he is 'a bungler' also the use of evil for this reason wouldn't be something you'd expect from a benevolent deity. Mccloskey is attributing evil to god, when in fact evil is due to the wickedness of man and his desire to misuse the freedom that god has given man however, there are humans who choose to not do evil and those who choose to do good. In the article mccloskey is critical of these arguments for god's existence supporting his stance by offering the problem of evil as reasoning to not believe he believes the belief in the existence of god is not a source of strength and security (2.
Many people, like mccloskey have dismissed the existence of god on the basis of the existence of evil the traditional theistic concept of god is that god is omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all-knowing) and benevolent (all-merciful) while the atheist hold that if god exists and is all these things then he could stop evil and prevent. Mccloskey is an australian philosopher who wrote a number of atheistic works in the 1960s and 70s including the book god and evil (nijhoff, 1974) in this article, mccloskey is both critical of the classical arguments for gods existence and offers the problem of evil as a reason why one should not believe in god. God and evil authors: maccloskey, henry john must a world created by an all-perfect being be wholly free of evil mccloskey, h j pages 70-77. A creation-order theodicy: god and gratuitous evil the central thesis of this extraordinary work is that the greater-good assumption associated with greater-good theodicies is unnecessary to the defense of theism and has actually strengthened the argument from evil by the atheist. Philosophical quarterly god and evil 101 theists admit this, and that the onus is on them to show that the conflict theists mccloskey god and evil.
Mccloskey wraps up his argument regarding evil as the evidence that god does not exist by stating, the existence of evil is therefore fatal to the claims that there is a supreme being who is perfect in every respect. - response to mccloskey introduction in his article on being an atheist, hj mccloskey, an australian philosopher took a serious stance on arguments against the existence of god he offered numerous reasons for the stance he took including, the problem with evil to suggest that one should not believe in god. Hj mccloskey moves through five common responses to the problem of physical evil and two proposals respectively to moral evil, with two criticisms of those proposals what is interesting to me is that mccloskey does not define evil in a single instance. Get this from a library god and evil [h j mccloskey] -- one sunny afternoon while everyone is resting, flamboyan, a young girl named after the tree whose red blossoms are the same color as her hair, dreamily flies over her caribbean island home.
Additional info for god and evil sample text in the light of these considerations, it is surprising that any theist should wish to ascribe power, all-power or omnipotence, to god in any but a literal sense. Works by h j mccloskey ( view other items matching `h j mccloskey`, view all matches) god and evil h j mccloskey - 1960 - philosophical quarterly 10. Alvin plantinga's free will defense is a logical argument developed by american analytic philosopher alvin plantinga, the john a o'brien professor of philosophy emeritus at the university of notre dame, and published in its final version in his 1977 book god, freedom, and evil. Mccloskey's main objection to theism is the presence of evil in the world and he raises it several times: no being who was perfect could have created a world in which there was avoidable suffering or in which his creatures would (and in fact could have been created so as not to) engage in morally evil acts, acts which very often result in. Response paper mccloskey article 1 response paper mccloskey article clark hernanser slideshare mccloskey attributes all evil to god first, the phrase is a.
In a penetrating paper, hj mccloskey considers a number of arguments in defense of god's existence when faced with the theological problem of evil. Mccloskey delves into both the cosmological and teleological arguments, which within he criticizes the arguments and to further his argument against theism, he also presents the problem of evil and why evil cannot possibly exist with a perfect god being the creator of universe. Essays - largest database of quality sample essays and research papers on god and evil mccloskey. Mccloskey is an australian philosopher who wrote a number of atheistic works in the 1960s and 70s including the book god and evil (nijhoff, 1974) in this article, mccloskey is both critical of the classical arguments for god's existence and offers the problem of evil as a reason why one should not believe in god.
Liberty university philosophical argument for the existence of god in response to hj mccloskey's on being an atheist a paper submitted to the faculty in candidacy for the degree of bachelor of science. God and evil by h s mccloskey starting at $1390 god and evil has 1 available editions to buy at alibris.
It will present a theological response to mccloskey's problems with evil as a way to disprove god's existence, and why god did not created free-will agents who always choose what is right lastly, the topic of atheism being more comforting than theism will be negated.